Fishing in Troubled Waters

Home | Author's Note | Articles List | EnviroLinks | Our Friends | What's New | Contact Us |

September 1998


Wouldn't you relish your shrimps so much more if you knew that the trawlers that brought in the catch on your plate hadn't ensnared endangered marine turtles? Or your tuna, knowing that it had been caught in purse seines that allowed dolphins to escape unharmed? Or your scallops, knowing that the sea bottom hadn't been dredged to get them? If your answer is YES, there's a bit of good news for you. Sometime in the foreseeable future, it will be possible for you to determine that the seafood you are buying is a product of responsible, sustainable fishing methods. The process of certification for seafood products is under way. When it is successfully put in place, marine products from certified fisheries may carry an on-pack logo like the "recycled" symbol that you are familiar with -- to assure consumers that the product conforms to international norms of sustainability and best fishery practice. Developing the certification standards is the Marine Stewardship Council (MSC), an independent, non-profit, non-government body formed in 1996 by the Worldwide Fund for Nature in partnership with Unilever.

But meanwhile...

The plunder of the oceans continues -- 1998: the UN Year of the Oceans has been of no "joy to the fishes of the deep blue sea" to quote the 1970's jingle.

No more than 50 years ago, most of the oceans were pristine wilderness, with seemingly inexhaustible resources. Modern fishing methods changed all that. Radar, sonar, electronic navigation and satellite positioning systems made locating fish increasingly precise. Giant nets, trawls, traps, lines and other indiscriminate fishing gear targeted marine life with scant consideration for species, age, gender, season, or location. Something considered unimaginable just a few decades ago has happened: man has stretched the limit of the seas to breaking point.

Over a million large "industrial'' fishing vessels - literally floating factories, equipped with facilities for cleaning and refrigeration, and support vessels serving as fuel tankers, repair shops, supply ships, research and scouting boats - and some two million smaller ones scour the world's oceans today, depleting one fish colony after the next. According to a UN Food and Agriculture Organisation report, 70 per cent of the world's commercially-important marine fish stocks are either fully fished, over-exploited, depleted, or slowly recovering. Even worse, as much as one-third of the annual global fish catch is wasted because it comprises unwanted species caught accidentally. Sea birds, turtles, mammals, inedible fish and other ocean life fall prey and are callously thrown overboard. Dead.


Consider the following...

  • Bluefin tuna: Virtually stripped from the North Atlantic. The spawning population of the northern bluefin in the western Atlantic has fallen by 90 per cent since 1975. These "Porsches of the seas'' - they are powerful, heavy and valuable - are tracked by spotter planes. Main cause of decline: delectable sushi, which can sell for as much as $200 a plate in a Tokyo sushi bar!

  • Sharks: Hunted in millions, besides being accidentally caught and killed as bycatch. Main causes of threat: sharkfin soup, the gourmet's delight! Also, a big market for meat, skin and cartilage.

  • Atlantic cod: declared commercially extinct. The Grand Banks cod fishery shut down in 1993. Main cause: demand for cod liver oil and meat.

  • Billfish: Gravely threatened. Killed either as game or as incidental bycatch in tuna and shark fisheries. Atlantic population has dropped 60-90 per cent since 1980, and are still falling. Main causes of decline: recreational (or sport) fishing as well as incidental catch in longline and purse-seine fisheries.

    The deep seas are a war zone...

    Scallop dredges bulldoze the sea floor, destroying sea grasses, coral reefs and seabed organisms. Shrimp and prawn trawlers devastate non-targeted species. Driftnets, longer than 2.5 km, are deployed in defiance of a UN moratorium on their use. Reef fishes are stunned with cyanide and captured for the trade in live coral reefs. Explosives are also used, annihilating entire marine communities.

    Where, then, does hope lie? International laws and treaties, such as the 1994 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS); or the 1995 UN Agreement on Straddling Fish Stocks and Highly Migratory Fish Stocks? Aquaculture and mariculture to ease pressure on marine fish resources? Political will? Certainly, YES. But, if one ,looks back at the more successful conservation efforts, they have worked largely on account of people's sentiments. The threat of consumer boycotts forced tuna-canning

    companies to import dolphin-safe tuna. It was primarily public opinion that outlawed commercial whaling almost the world over. Consumer pressure in the West is now growing for shrimp trawling that doesn't hurt turtles. Environmental considerations are becoming increasingly important for consumers in making purchasing decisions.

    This is why eco-labelling for marine products through the Marine Stewardship Council is such a significant move. The MSC will, for the first time, make it easier for consumers to choose.

    WHAT ON EARTH CAN WE DO?

    Whenever possible, buy products made from recycled materials. These could include bottles, tissue rolls and stationery.

    Home | Author's Note | List of Articles | EnviroLinks | Our Friends | What's New | Contact Us |

  • Copyright © 1998-2002 [Earthsense from Rashmi De Roy]